Traditional SEO gets you ranked in Google's blue links through keywords, backlinks and technical optimisation. AI SEO gets you cited in AI-generated answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google's AI Overviews and similar platforms. The goal shifts from ranking positions to being the source AI systems trust and cite.
They're not competing strategies though. They're complementary. Strong traditional SEO actually helps your AI SEO, and vice versa.
Article Summary:
The Core Difference: Rankings vs Citations
The search landscape has changed fundamentally. A few years ago, SEO meant getting your pages to rank in Google. That was it. Today, people find information through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google's AI Overviews and other AI-powered platforms.
While traditional SEO remains important it is no longer the only factor. You need to understand how these different approaches vary, to enhance your visibility across all these channels.
Traditional SEO and AI SEO chase fundamentally different outcomes. The aim of traditional SEO is to rank your pages in search results; you want position one or at least first page. Success means appearing in that list of ten blue links when people search relevant terms.
AI SEO aims to get you cited as a source in AI-generated answers. You're not trying to rank in a list. You want the AI system to reference your content when it synthesises responses to user queries. Success means being the authority the AI trusts enough to cite.
This shift changes everything about how you approach optimisation.
Here's how it plays out differently:
Traditional SEO and AI SEO weight different factors when determining what deserves visibility. Understanding these differences helps you optimise effectively for both.
Backlinks matter enormously for traditional SEO. Hundreds or thousands of quality links build domain authority that takes years to establish. AI systems care less about your link profile. They care more about whether your information is accurate and well-sourced.
Traditional SEO lets you build authority gradually through consistent work over time. AI SEO can recognise quality content relatively quickly if it's genuinely authoritative and well-structured. This creates opportunities for newer sites to compete in AI search whilst they're still building traditional SEO authority.
Traditional SEO and AI SEO weight different factors when determining what deserves visibility. Understanding these differences helps you optimise effectively for both.
Backlinks matter enormously for traditional SEO. Hundreds or thousands of quality links build domain authority that takes years to establish. AI systems care less about your link profile. They care more about whether your information is accurate and well-sourced.
Traditional SEO lets you build authority gradually through consistent work over time. AI SEO can recognise quality content relatively quickly if it's genuinely authoritative and well-structured. This creates opportunities for newer sites to compete in AI search whilst they're still building traditional SEO authority.
How you create and structure content needs to account for both traditional search algorithms and AI comprehension.
Traditional SEO content targets specific keywords. You research terms people search, then create pages optimised around those terms. Keyword placement in titles, headings and throughout content signals relevance. Internal linking passes authority between pages. External links from quality sites boost rankings.
Content length matters less than keyword relevance and user engagement. A 500 word page perfectly matching search intent can outrank a 2,000 word page that goes off topic. The goal is satisfying the specific query that brought users to your page.
AI SEO content needs to be comprehensive and authoritative. Superficial coverage doesn't cut it because AI systems can compare your content against everything else on the topic. Depth signals expertise.
You structure content around questions people ask conversationally rather than just keywords. Answer questions directly, then provide supporting context. Use clear headings that help AI systems extract information accurately. Implement proper schema markup so AI understands your content structure, authorship and expertise signals.
Citations and sources matter more. AI systems check factual accuracy. Show your research. Cite reputable sources. Demonstrate that you're not just making claims but backing them with evidence.
The good news? You don't have to choose. Quality content serves both purposes. Write comprehensively about topics (AI SEO) whilst naturally incorporating relevant keywords (traditional SEO). Create clear structure helping both search engines and AI systems understand your content. Build genuine expertise that both approaches reward. The overlap is substantial.
The technical side of optimisation shifts focus between traditional and AI approaches, though again there's significant overlap.
Notice the overlap? Both need fast page speeds, mobile optimisation, and clean, accessible content.
The difference is emphasis. Traditional SEO focuses heavily on crawlability and indexation but AI SEO focuses on comprehension and context.
Smart implementation addresses both. Implement schema markup properly, and you help both traditional search engines and AI systems understand your content better. Optimise page speed, and you improve traditional rankings whilst ensuring AI systems can access your content efficiently.
How you measure success differs between traditional and AI SEO because the outcomes you're chasing are fundamentally different.
Traditional SEO metrics are relatively easy to track. Tools like Google Search Console show exactly where you rank and how much traffic you're getting. You can track progress month over month with clear numbers.
AI SEO metrics require more manual work. You need to actually query AI platforms to see if they cite you. Referral traffic helps but doesn't show the full picture because not all citations drive immediate clicks. Brand awareness from citations matters even without direct traffic, making measurement less precise but no less important.
Traditional and AI SEO operate on different timelines, and understanding these differences helps set realistic expectations.
Traditional SEO takes time. Expect 3 to 6 months minimum for meaningful results with competitive keywords. New sites need longer because they're building domain authority from scratch. Established sites can see faster improvements because they have existing authority to leverage.
Backlink building happens gradually. You can't rush quality link acquisition without risking penalties. Domain authority accumulates over years through consistent work. There are no real shortcuts. Anyone promising quick rankings is either targeting very easy keywords or using risky tactics.
AI SEO can show results faster for quality content. If you publish genuinely authoritative content on a topic, AI systems might cite it within weeks rather than months. They're not waiting for backlinks to accumulate. They're assessing content quality and accuracy more directly.
However, building consistent citations across multiple queries still takes time. You need comprehensive topical coverage. One great article might get cited once. Becoming the go-to authority on subjects requires building depth across related topics. That sustained effort takes months, similar to traditional SEO.
Work on both simultaneously. Your traditional SEO efforts compound over time whilst AI SEO might deliver earlier wins. The traditional authority you build strengthens AI SEO performance. The expertise you demonstrate through AI citations can attract backlinks helping traditional SEO. They feed each other when done well.
Traditional and AI SEO aren't competing strategies. They're complementary approaches addressing different parts of how people find information today.
Traditional search isn't dead. Google still processes billions of queries daily. People still click through organic results. Your traditional SEO work still drives traffic and revenue. You can't abandon it.
But AI-powered search is growing rapidly. ChatGPT has hundreds of millions of users. Google's AI Overviews appear on increasing numbers of searches. Perplexity continues gaining adoption. These platforms represent a significant user segments you cannot ignore. Optimising for traditional search only means missing these audiences.
Traditional and AI SEO reinforce each other:
You don't need separate teams or strategies, only one unified approach addressing both traditional and AI search realities. Smart businesses integrate both approaches:
The fundamentals overlap significantly. Quality content, technical excellence and demonstrated expertise work everywhere.
We don't treat traditional and AI SEO as separate projects; they're integrated components of comprehensive search visibility. Our integrated strategy includes:
Integrated approaches avoid duplication and wasted effort. You're not creating separate content for traditional and AI search.; you're creating excellent content that performs well everywhere. You're not implementing separate technical foundations; you're building solid infrastructure that serves all purposes.
This efficiency delivers better results faster. You're not splitting resources between competing strategies. You're focusing everything on building genuine authority and expertise that search engines and AI systems both recognise and reward.
Mid Wales Marketing helps Welsh businesses build comprehensive search visibility across traditional search engines and AI platforms.
Our integrated SEO strategies ensure you're visible wherever your audience searches. Whether they're using Google, ChatGPT, Perplexity or any other platform, you appear as the trusted authority in your field.
Contact Mid Wales Marketing today to discuss how integrated SEO can strengthen your visibility across all search channels whilst making efficient use of your marketing budget.
Areas Served:
Aberystwyth, Bangor, Brecon, Builth Wells, Caernarfon, Colwyn Bay, Holyhead,
Llandrindod Wells, Llandudno, Machynlleth, Mold, Newtown, Rhyl, Welshpool and Wrexham
© 2025 All Rights Reserved
Mid Wales Marketing, Darowen, Machynlleth SY20 8BW
Ph 01654 288007
Mid Wales Marketing is a regional initiative of Mark Woodcock, founder of Bigfoot Digital and Bigfoot Agency A.I.
